· Updated

In February 2023, the Commercial Register Act (äriregistri seadus, ÄRS) entered into force in Estonia, bringing a number of legislative changes and innovations concerning the formal side, reporting and liability of legal persons. Previously, Commercial Register matters were governed by the Commercial Code (äriseadustik), in which some important changes were also made in connection with the adoption of the Commercial Register Act.
Sanctions for failing to submit the annual report have become stricter
This article focuses on the provisions of the Commercial Register Act that regulate the changes concerning failure to submit the annual report. Under the new provisions, the sanctions have become considerably stricter, primarily because failure to submit annual reports, or submitting them late, is a common phenomenon in the Estonian business environment.
There are various reasons why annual reports are not submitted. There are situations where this is done in bad faith, in order to conceal the company's real data, for example from the company's other shareholders and business partners, but there are also cases where the company has essentially been "abandoned" by its owners and management board, which means that the company has in practice ceased its activities, but the shareholders do not want to initiate proper liquidation proceedings. Such a situation creates a misleading picture of the Estonian business landscape, which the legislator cannot accept, because the reputation and reliability of our business environment depend on it
Imposing a fine for failing to submit the annual report has become easier (ÄRS § 57)
Previously, the registrar had the right to impose a fine on a legal person that had not submitted its annual report on time if the legal person had disregarded a warning order. Under the amendment, the registrar has the right to impose a fine on a legal person for failing to submit the annual report even without a warning order.
The registrar now has considerably more discretion than before in determining the amount of the fine, which depends on the following circumstances:
- how many times the annual report has not been submitted on time;
- how much time has passed since the deadline by which the annual report should have been submitted;
- other circumstances known to the registrar.
A fine may be imposed repeatedly until the annual report is submitted. In addition to the legal person, a fine can also be imposed personally on the management board and shareholders of the legal person, as they have a statutory obligation to submit the report.
Deletion from the register for failing to submit the annual report happens sooner (ÄRS § 61)
Under the new law, the registrar has the right to delete a legal person from the register if the deadline set by the registrar for submitting the report is not met and at least three months have passed since the statutory deadline for submitting the report.
Whereas previously the Commercial Code gave at least six months after the warning order to prepare and submit annual reports, under the Commercial Register Act the legal person must submit the annual report within the deadline specified in the warning order. Practice will show how long the deadline under the new law turns out to be in reality.
Compared to the past, the registrar no longer has to wait six months after the deadline for submitting the annual report before sending a warning order to the legal person. This can be done immediately after the deadline has passed, i.e. for many entrepreneurs from 1 July. A deletion warning does not preclude the imposition of a fine (or fines) at the same time.
In summary
In short, the legislator has made it a priority for the Commercial Register to put pressure on entrepreneurs to submit their annual reports in order to step up the cleaning up of the data in the Commercial Register. Proper reporting has a significant impact on the health and reliability of the Estonian business environment. One of the functions of the Commercial Register is to give entrepreneurs the opportunity to obtain information about both existing and potential business partners, providing greater clarity when making decisions and building business relationships. It is therefore necessary that the register contains all the required information about companies, including correct annual reports submitted on time.
Our recommendations:
- Check in the e-Business Register portal (ettevõtjaportaal) that your annual reports have definitely been submitted. It sometimes comes as a surprise that the reports have been prepared but not submitted. In most cases, the reason is that a shareholder's signature is missing and the report has therefore not been submitted, or the signatures are there but the submit button has not been clicked.
- Do not rely on the hope that the Commercial Register may not be able to deal with everyone at once and that this time your company might escape checks and sanctions. Many activities in the Commercial Register are automated, and they are becoming more efficient every day. We have noticed that fines are already being imposed more frequently and that the register is using its right to impose fines more forcefully than before.
- If you know that your annual reports have not been prepared and submitted, we recommend finding a way to deal with the matter immediately. The longer you put it off, the higher your costs and the time involved are likely to be. Wisecounter's consultants and accountants are always happy to help you with all accounting and tax matters – we help prepare and submit annual reports and put your accounting in order should this be necessary.